A systematic literature review on community relocation in the historic urban contexts

Azarnoush, M.; Esfanjari Kenari, E.; Ghaffari, A.; Pereira Roders, A.

doi:10.22034/IJHCUM.2022.04.07

Document Type : REVIEW PAPER

Authors

¹ Department of Conservation and Restoration of Historic Building and Sites, Faculty of Conservation and Restoration, Art University of Isfahan, Isfahan, Iran

² Department of Urban and Regional Design and Planning, Faculty of Architecture and Urbanism, Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran, Iran

³ Department of Architectural Engineering + Technology, Faculty of Architecture and the Built Environment, Delft University of Technology, Delft, Netherlands

https://doi.org/10.22034/IJHCUM.2022.04.07

Abstract

Community relocation could be voluntary or forced, but such change in the composition of inhabitants can endanger the historic urban context and its cultural significance. So, finding the answer to these questions is crucial: What are the main factors for relocation in historic urban contexts, and are these areas affected differently? This paper presented and discussed the results of a systematic literature review of international English-language publications. Databases such as Scopus, ICOMOS Open Archive, and UNESCO digital library were investigated to reveal the main factors for community relocation in the historic urban contexts. Results revealed a frequent focus in metropolitan regions and major cities worldwide between 1987 and 2021. The multiplicity of non-environmental relocation factors was also noticeable. Despite the commonalities of factors for community relocation worldwide, the type and effect of the relocation differed between the historic urban context and other urban contexts. The interaction of two main factors, namely economics and policies, was found to affect the process of community relocation in the historic urban context the most. Forced relocation was more predominant than voluntary relocation in historic urban contexts. However, the existing relations between internal and external factors that drive relocation must be further investigated. This research identified and charted how the local community relocation in historic urban contexts that are reflected in scholars’ publications. It also defined a theoretical framework on the factors of community relocation in these contexts and their interrelation, which is vital for both urban and heritage studies as well as planning practices.

Keywords

Main Subjects

Urban social and cultural welfare

References

Abastante, F.; Lami, I.M.; Mecca, B., (2020). How to revitalise a historic district: A stakeholders-oriented assessment framework of adaptive Reuse. Values and Functions for Future Cities. Springer Verlag, 3-20 (18 pages).

Akkar Ercan, M., (2011). Challenges and conflicts in achieving sustainable communities in historic neighbourhoods of Istanbul’. Habitat International. Elsevier Ltd, 35(2): 295-306 (12 pages).

Aleksandrowicz, O.; Yamu, C.; Van Nes, A., (2017). The socio-spatial development of jaffa-tel aviv: The emergence and fade-away of ethnic divisions and distinctions. Proceedings - 11th International Space Syntax Symposium. SSS 2017, (140): 1-20 (20 pages).

Amin, H.M.T.M., (2018). The impact of heritage decline on urban social life. J. Environ. Psychol. Elsevier Ltd, 55: 34-47 (14 pages).

Ammon, F.R., (2018). Resisting gentrification amid historic preservation: Society Hill, Philadelphia, and the fight for low-income housing. Change Over Time, 8(1): 8-31 (24 pages).

Appler, D.R., (2016). Affordable housing in National Register districts: recognizing the advantages of historic urban neighborhoods in Louisville and Covington, Kentucky, USA, J. URBAN. Routledge, 9(3): 237-253 (17 pages).

Arslanli, K.Y.; Dökmecı, V.; Kolcu, H., (2017). The effect of the pedestrianization of İstiklal caddesi on land values and the transformation of urban land use. A/Z ITU J. Fac. Archit., 14(2): 31-41 (11 pages).

Atkinson, R., (2004). The evidence on the impact of gentrification: New lessons for the urban renaissance. Eur. J. Hous. Policy., 4(1): 107-131 (25 pages).

Axenov, K., (2014). Between degradation and gentrification in a post-transformational metropolis city center: The case of St. Petersburg. Eurasian Geogr. Econ. Routledge, 55(6): 656-673 (17 pages).

Baiocchi, V.; Zottele, F.; Dominici, D., (2017). Remote sensing of urban microclimate change in L’Aquila city (Italy) after post-earthquake depopulation in an open source GIS environment. Sensors (Switzerland), 17(2): 1-12 (12 pages).

Barnett, J.; Beckman, J., (2006). Reconstructing new orleans: A progress report. In Rebuilding Urban Places After Disaster: Lessons from Hurricane Katrina, edited by Eugenie Birch and Susan Wachter, 288-304 (17 pages).

Berényi, I., (1994). Transformation of the urban structure of Budapest. GeoJournal, 32(4): 403-414 (12 pages).

Bertocchi, D.; Visentin, F., (2019). The overwhelmed city: Physical and social over-capacities of global tourism in Venice. Sustainability (Switzerland)., 11(24) (19 pages).

Bose, K., (2018). Revival of Kolkata’s Chinatown: Democracy and its Role in Safeguarding the Heritage of Ethnic Minorities in India., in ICOMOS 19th General Assembly and Scientific Symposium ‘Heritage and Democracy’ (8 pages).

Boussaa, D., (2014a). The Social sustainability of historic centers in north Africa: Cases from Algiers, Tunis, and Fez. Int. J. Sustainability Econ. Social Cult. Context., 9(3): 69-83 (15 pages).

Boussaa, D., (2014b). The Kasbah of Dellys in Algeria, revitalization and conservation through tourism. Vernacular Architecture: Towards a Sustainable Future - Proceedings of the International Conference on Vernacular Heritage, Sustainability and Earthen Architecture., 169-174 (6 pages).

Boussaa, D., (2020). The past as a catalyst for cultural sustainability in historic cities; the case of Doha, Qatar. Int. J. Heritage Stud. Routledge, 27(5): 470-486 (17 pages).

Bowen, D.S., (2003). The transformation of Richmond’s historic African American commercial corridor. Southeast. Geogr., 43(2): 260-278 (19 pages).

Burgos-Vigna, D., (2017). Quito, a World Heritage City or a city to live in?: Right to the city and right to heritage in the “Good Living State”. City. Taylor & Francis, 21(5): 550-567 (18 pages).

Caffio, G., (2018). Drawing for the future: Micro-cities, villages and landscapes of abruzzo. Lecture Notes in Civil Engineering, 3: 949-956 (8 pages).

Chai, N.; Choi, M.J., (2012). The utilization planning of historic and cultural buildings in declined region: In the case of Gongrencun region in Shenyang city of China. Adv. Mater. Res., 361-363: 1109-1116 (8 pages).

Chen, Y.; Yang, J., (2018). The Chinese socio-cultural sustainability approach: The impact of conservation planning on local population and residential mobility. Sustainability (Switzerland), 10(11): (18 pages).

Clarke, N.J.; Corten, J.A.M., (2011). Regenerating pretoria’s historical core. ICOMOS 17th General Assembly (12 pages).

Cutrufo, J.D., (2011). Boston: We hardly knew you: Change is the byword in the city’s neighborhoods. Planning, 77(1): 10-15 (6 pages).

Davis, M., (2002). Reconfiguring urban topography - New paradigms for older cities. Adv. Archit. Ser., 14: 143-151 (9 pages).

Davoodi, T.; Dağli, U.U., (2019). Exploring the determinants of residential satisfaction in historic urban quarters: Towards sustainability of the Walled City Famagusta, North Cyprus. Sustainability (Switzerland), 11(22) (25 pages).

Evans, E.; Grosicki, B., (2017). Data-driven rightsizing: integrating preservation into the legacy cities landscape. ISPRS Ann. Photogramm. Remote Sens. Spatial Inf. Sci., IV-2/W2(2W2): 83-89 (7 pages).

Ferreira, J.P.; Ramos, P.N.; Lahr, M.L., (2020). The rise of the sharing economy: Guesthouse boom and the crowding-out effects of tourism in Lisbon. Tourism Econ., 26(3): 389-403 (15 pages).

Fischer, T., Osterreicher, D., (2019). Persons Entitled to Asylum Create their Own Living Space - Conditions for a Successful Implementation in Rural Areas in Austria, in IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering (8 pages).

Gillick, A.R., (2017). Stitching the city: Continuity, urban renewal and grassroots action in Late-Twentieth century glasgow. J. Archit., 22(2): 188-224 (37 pages).

Goetz, E.G., (2002). Forced relocation vs. voluntary mobility: The effects of dispersal programmes on households. Hous. Stud., 17(1): 107-123 (17 pages).

Gonzalez, E.G.; Overgaard, R.P.; Delgado, J.C., (2005). Historical, ethic and urbanistic background at Monterrey, Mexico. 5th ICOMOS General Assembly and International Symposium: ‘Monuments and sites in their setting - conserving cultural heritage in changing townscapes and landscapes (7 pages).

Gosling, D., (1992). Urban edges and the public realm. Cities, 9(2): 101-110 (10 pages).

Greenbaum, S.D., (1990). Marketing Ybor City: Race, Ethnicity, and Historic Preservation in the Sunbelt. City Soc., 4(1): 58-76 (19 pages).

Griffin, T.L.; Cramer, D.; Powers, M., (2014). Detroit works long-term planning project: Engagement strategies for blending community and technical expertise. Buildings, 4(4): 711-736 (26 pages).

Grima, R., (2017). Heritage Management, Tourism, and World Heritage on Malta, American Anthropologist, 119(1): 125-127 (3 pages).

Kitchin, R.; Thrift, N., (2009). International encyclopedia of human geography. Elsevier.

Hatch, M.E., (2020). Voluntary, forced, and induced renter mobility: The influence of state policies. Journal of Housing Economics. Elsevier Inc. (49 pages).

Heathcott, J., (2006). Score one for modernism in St. Louis. Planning, 72(11): 42-43 (2 pages).

Hollander, J.B., (2013). Contemporary perceptions of nine decades of depopulation in New Bedford, Massachusetts. Urban Des. Int., 18(1): 6-23 (18 pages).

Hollander, J.B.; Hartt, M.D.; Wiley, A.; Vavra, S., (2018). Vacancy in shrinking downtowns: a comparative study of Québec, Ontario, and New England. J. Hous. Built Environ. Springer Netherlands, 33(4): 591-613 (23 pages).

Huang, Y.C.; Chen, S.M., (2014). Study on the regeneration of urban historical area from the viewpoint of workshops matchmaking local participations, Appl. Mech. Mater., 587-589: 48-56 (9 pages).

Hwang, K.H., (2014). Finding urban identity through culture-led urban regeneration. J. Urban Manage., 3(1-2): 67-85 (19 pages).

Jover, J.; Díaz-Parra, I., (2020). Gentrification, transnational gentrification and touristification in Seville, Spain. Urban Stud., 57(15): 3044-3059 (16 pages).

Kaufman, N., (2012). When cities shrink: redefining roles for conservation, development and investment., in ICOMOS 17th General Assembly, 106-113 (8 pages).

Keating, L., (2000). Redeveloping public housing: Relearning urban renewal’s immutable lessons. J. Am. Plann. Assoc., 66(4): 384-397 (14 pages).

Kim, E.; Lee, S., (2020). Sustainability and the expected effects of office-to-residential conversion in historic downtown areas of South Korea. Sustainability (Switzerland), 12(22): 1-18 (18 pages).

Knowles, S.G., (2009). Staying too long at the fair: Philadelphia planning and the debacle of 1976, in Imagining Philadelphia: Edmund Bacon and The Future of The City, 78-111 (34 pages).

Kristianova, K.; Jaszczak, A., (2020). Historical centers of small cities in Slovakia – Problems and potentials of creating livable public spaces. IOP Conf. Ser.: Mater. Sci. Eng. 960. (6 pages).

London, M., (2003). Heritage preservation and the Lachine Canal revitalization project. Plan Canada, 43(2): 33-35 (3 pages).

Longoria, R.; Rogers, S., (2013). Exodus within an expanding city: The case of Houston’s historic African-American communities. Urban Des. Int., 18(1): 24-42 (19 pages).

Lopes, A.C.; Rodrigues, E.B.; Vera-Cruz, R., (2019). Tourism gentrification. IOP Conf. Ser.: Mater. Sci. Eng. 471. (6 pages).

López-Morales, E.; Shin, H.B.; Lees, L., (2016). Latin american gentrifications. Urban Geogr. Routledge, 37(8): 1091-1108 (18 pages).

Lung Ping Yee, D.; Lee Ho, Y.; Chow Tsz, Y.E., (2005). The changing rural setting of hong kong’s new territories in the 20^th centry. 15th ICOMOS general assembly and international symposium: Monuments and sites in their setting - conserving cultural heritage in changing townscapes and lanscapes (8 pages).

Maher, T.; Haas, A., (1987). Suburbanizing the city. Sociological Focus, 20(4): 281-294 (14 pages).

McCabe, S., (2005). The Springfield technical community college technology park—a creative use of real estate: Converting a derelict property into an economic development engine, Community Coll. J. Res. Pract., 29(8): 599-607 (9 pages).

Medeiros, E.; van der Zwet, A., (2020). Sustainable and integrated urban planning and governance in metropolitan and medium-sized cities, Sustainability (Switzerland), 12(15) (19 pages).

Mínguez, C.; Piñeira, M.J.; Fernández-Tabales, A., (2019). Social vulnerability and touristification of historic centers. Sustainability (Switzerland), 11(16): 1-24 (24 pages).

Moher, D.; Liberati, A.; Tetzlaff, J.; Altman, D.G.; Altman, D.; The prisma group, (2009). Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-Analyses: The prisma statement. PLOS Med., 6(7): e1000097 (6 pages).

Morckel, V.C., (2017). Using suitability analysis to prioritize demolitions in a legacy city. Urban Geogr., 38(1): 90-111 (22 pages).

Nadalin, V.; Igliori, D., (2017). Empty spaces in the crowd. Residential vacancy in São Paulo’s city centre. Urban Stud., 54(13): 3085-3100 (16 pages).

Naeem, A., (2008). Shikapoor: de-spirited and defamed waiting to be salvaged. 16th ICOMOS General Assembly and International Symposium: ‘Finding the spirit of place – between the tangible and the intangible’ (12 pages).

Ng, M.K., (2015). Knowledge and power in regenerating lived space in Treasure Hill, Taipei 1960s–2010: from squatter settlement to a co-living artist village. Plann. Perspect., 30(2): 253-270 (18 pages).

Nix, E.M.; Hollowak, T.; Elfenbein, J., (2011). Pivot in perception the impact of the 1968 riots on three baltimore business districts. Baltimore ’68: Riots and rebirth in an American city. Temple university press: 180-207 (28 pages).

Phillips, B.; Stukes, P.A.; Jenkins, P., (2012). Freedom Hill is not for sale-and neither is the Lower Ninth Ward. J. Black Stud., 43(4): 405-426 (22 pages).

Queirós, J.; Pereira, V.B., (2018). Voices in the revolution: Resisting territorial stigma and social relegation in Porto’s historic centre (1974-1976). Sociological Rev., 66(4): 857-876 (20 pages).

Raony Silva, E.; Donegan, L., (2019). Building transformations in old Jo O Pessoa (Brazil): Spatial form impacts on uses and levels of built heritage conservation. Proceedings of 12th International Space Syntax Symposium, SSS 2019. (18 pages).

Ryberg-Webster, S., (2016). Heritage amid an urban crisis: Historic preservation in Cleveland, Ohio’s Slavic Village neighborhood. Cities. Elsevier Ltd, 58: 10-25 (16 pages).

Ryberg-Webster, S., (2019). Community development and historic preservation: Exploring intersections in Seattle’s Chinatown-International District. Community Dev. J., 54(2): 290-309 (20 pages).

Ryberg-Webster, S.; Ashley, A.J., (2018). The nexus of arts and preservation: A case study of Cleveland’s Detroit shoreway community development organization. Change Over Time, 8(1): 32-52 (21 pages).

Ryberg-Webster, S.; Kinahan, K.L., (2017). Historic preservation in declining city neighbourhoods: Analysing rehabilitation tax credit investments in six US cities, Urban Stud., 54(7): 1673-1691 (19 pages).

Salvati, L.; De Rosa, S., (2014). ‘Hidden Polycentrism’ or ‘Subtle Dispersion’? Urban growth and long-term sub-centre dynamics in three Mediterranean cities, Land Use Policy. Elsevier Ltd, 39: 233-243 (11 pages).

Sampson, N.R.; Webster, N.J.; Nassauer, J.I.; Schulz, A.J., (2019). Adapting social surveys to depopulating neighborhoods, Landscape and Urban Planning. Elsevier, 181: 45-50 (6 pages).

Sequera, J.; Nofre, J., (2020). Touristification, transnational gentrification and urban change in Lisbon: The neighbourhood of Alfama. Urban Stud., 57(15): 3169-3189 (21 pages).

Spirou C.; Gardner, S.; Spears, M.; Allegretti, A., (2020). The Sweet Auburn Historic District in Atlanta: Heritage Tourism, Urban Regeneration, and the Civil Rights Movement Costas. Wise, N. and Jimura, T. (eds) Tourism, Cultural Heritage and Urban Regeneration. Springer, 205-213 (8 pages).

Szívós, E., (2015). Turbulent history, troublesome heritage: Political change, social transformation, and the possibilities of revival in the “old Jewish quarter” of Budapest. Hung. Stud., 29(1-2): 93-120 (28 pages).

Tintěra J.; Kotval, Z.; Ruus, A.; Tohvri, E., (2018). Inadequacies of heritage protection regulations in an era of shrinking communities: a case study of Valga, Estonia. Eur. Plann. Stud., 26(12): 2448-2469 (22 pages).

Todescini, F., (2003). Some reflections on place, tangible and intangible heritage and on identity construction. 14th ICOMOS General Assembly and International Symposium: ‘Place, memory, meaning: preserving intangible values in monuments and sites’ (5 pages).

Toprak, I.; Ünlü, A.; Van Nes, A., (2017). Diachronic assessment of cultural diversity in historic neighbourhoods using space syntax: Studies of three neighbourhoods in Istanbul. 11th Space Syntax Symposium(SSS 2017). Instituto Superior Técnico, Lisbon: 154.1-154.14 (14 pages).

Torkington, K.; Ribeiro, F.P., (2020). Whose right to the city? An analysis of the mediatized politics of place surrounding alojamento local issues in Lisbon and Porto. J. Sustainable Tourism, 1-20 (20 pages).

Werkneh, M., (2017). Retaking mecca: Healing Harlem through restorative just compensation. Columbia J. Law Social Probl., 51(2): 225-273 (49 pages).

Xie, S.; Batunova, E., (2020). Shrinking historic neighborhoods and authenticity dilution: An unspoken challenge of historic chinatowns in the United States through the case of San Francisco. Sustainability (Switzerland), 12(1): 1-20 (20 pages).

Yakubu I.E.; Egbelakin, T.; Dizhur, D.; Ingham, J.; Park, K.S.; Phipps, R., (2017). Why are older inner-city buildings vacant? Implications for town centre regeneration. J. Urban Regener. Renew., 11(1): 44-59 (16 pages).

Yang, P.Y.; Hsu, S.L., (2018). Stakeholder viewpoint of island cultural heritage protection – case study of Kinmen and Xiamen. ICOMOS 19th General Assembly and Scientific Symposium ‘Heritage and Democracy’. (8 pages).

Yapeng, O., (2018). Emerging civic engagement in the revitalization of minor historic centers, cases from Reggio Calabria, Italy. ICOMOS 19th General Assembly and Scientific Symposium ‘Heritage and Democracy’. (10 pages).

Zanini, S., (2017). Tourism pressures and depopulation in Cannaregio: Effects of mass tourism on Venetian cultural heritage. J. Cult. Heritage Manage. Sustain. Dev., 7(2): 164-178 (15 pages).

Zhe, M.; Wang, X., (2012), June. A proposal for enhancing the role of tourist industry in residents conversation in heritage city. In 2012 6th International Association for China Planning Conference (IACP),IEEE. 1-12 (12 pages).

LETTERS TO EDITOR

International Journal of Human Capital in Urban Management (IJHCUM) welcomes letters to the editor for the post-publication discussions and corrections which allows debate post publication on its site, through the Letters to Editor. Letters pertaining to manuscript published in IJHCUM should be sent to the editorial office of IJHCUM within three months of either online publication or before printed publication, except for critiques of original research. Following points are to be considering before sending the letters (comments) to the editor.

[1] Letters that include statements of statistics, facts, research, or theories should include appropriate references, although more than three are discouraged.

[2] Letters that are personal attacks on an author rather than thoughtful criticism of the author’s ideas will not be considered for publication.

[3] Letters can be no more than 300 words in length.

[4] Letter writers should include a statement at the beginning of the letter stating that it is being submitted either for publication or not.

[5] Anonymous letters will not be considered.

[6] Letter writers must include their city and state of residence or work.

[7] Letters will be edited for clarity and length.

Name *

Email Address *

Affiliation *

Comments *

Security Code *

International Journal of Human Capital in Urban Management

A systematic literature review on community relocation in the historic urban contexts

References

References

Send comment about this article

Volume 7, Issue 4 - Serial Number 28
October 2022
Pages 529-544

A systematic literature review on community relocation in the historic urban contexts

References

References

Send comment about this article

Volume 7, Issue 4 - Serial Number 28October 2022Pages 529-544

Volume 7, Issue 4 - Serial Number 28
October 2022
Pages 529-544