1 Department of Management, Kish International Branch, Islamic Azad University, Kish Island, Iran

2 Department of Business Administration and MBA, Payame Noor University, Tehran, Iran

3 Department of Management and Economics, Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran

4 Department of Management, South Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran


This study aims to conceptualize business excellence model and identify its variables and indicators. The philosophical foundations of the pragmatic, humanistic theory of symbolic interactionism has been, quietly and the strategy of grand theory deal with open, axial and selective coding; whose output is a new concept. Data collection is based on documentation studies on excellence models. The population under study more specifically includes the models existing in prestigious journals and magazines with theoretical sampling logic in order to reach theoretical saturation. To measure validity, Critical Appraisal Skills Program was applied and to assess reliability, two encoders were used. Reliability was calculated to be 0.86 through the agreement between two encoders and Kappa coefficient for 102 samples; the reliability was good. For analysis, MAXQDA‌ ‌software has been employed. Out of 102 conceptual excellence models under investigation in the coding step, 869 concepts or open codes were obtained. Common basic codes were divided into 50 major categories in terms of meaning, which, in the selective coding step, led to the creation of five dimensions with the names of people, market, work, management and the underlying factors. The conducted study is a small step towards the extraction of indicators and concepts of business excellence from 102 classic models.

Graphical Abstract

Conceptualization of business excellence model with a grand theory approach


Main Subjects

Aaker, D.A.; Equity, M.B., 1991. The Free Press. New York, 206.

Aaker, D.A., (1996). Measuring brand equity across products and markets. Calif. Manage. Rev., 38 (3): 102- 121 (20 pages).

Aaker, J.L., (1997). Dimensions of brand personality. J. Marketing Res, 34(3):347-356 (10 pages).

Afjeh, S.A.A.; Taghi Pourfar, V.; Azar, A.; Jafarpour, M., (2014). A Comprehensive Model of Organizational Justice with an Islamic Approach. J. Manage. Stud. Improv. Evol., 23 )74(: 21-47 (28 pages). (In Persian)

Aguilar, F.J., (1967). Scanning the business environment. Macmillan.

akbari emami, s.; mashbaki, a.; khodadad hoseini, s, h.; kordnaij, a,. (2015). designing the behavior pattern for successful strategy implementation. J. Resour. Mmanage. Res., 20 (1):103 -130 (28 pages). (In Persian)

Albliwi, S.A.; Antony, J.; Arshed, N., (2014). December. Critical literature review on maturity models for business process excellence. Ind. Eng. Manage., 79-83 (5 pages).

Ambler, S., (2002). Agile modeling: effective practices for extreme programming and the unified process. John Wiley and Sons.

Amir Bolboli, S.; Reiche, M., (2013). A model for sustainable business excellence: implementation and the roadmap. TQM J., 25(4), 331-346 (16 pages)

Andersen, E.S.; Jessen, S.A., (2003). Project maturity in organizations. Int. J. Proj. Manag., 21(6):457-461 (5 pages).

Ansoff, H.I., (1987). The concept of corporate strategy. Homewood, IL: Irwin.

Arabi, s, M.; Mostafavi, A., (2011). The integrated model of marketing and business marketing strategies and their impact on organizational performance. J. Im. Manage. Stud., 18 (64): 89 -116 (28 pages). (In Persian).

Arabshahi, A., (2015).Designing and explaining of transcendental organization model with Islamic approach (Case Study: Higher education institutions in Mashhad). J. Manage. Dev. Proc., 27 (4): 3-24 (22 pages). (In Persian).

Asgharnejad Nouri, B.; Sanaiei, A.; Fathi, S.; Kazemi, A., (2014). Meta-analysis of the moderating role of sample characteristics in relation between marketing activities and organizational performance. J. Manage. Res., 18(1): 51 -169 (19 pages). (In Persian)

Balbastre-Benavent, F.; Canet-Giner, M.T., (2011). The strategy formation process in the EFQM Excellence Model: a critical review and new perspectives. Total Qual. Manage. Bus., 22(7): 727-742 (16 pages).

Becker, C.L.; DeFond, M.L.; Jiambalvo, J.; Subramanyam, K.R., (1998). The effect of audit quality on earnings management. Contemp. Account Res., 15(1):1-24 (24 pages).

Beer, M., (2015). HRM at a crossroads: Comments on “Evolution of strategic HRM through two founding books: A 30th anniversary perspective on development of the field”. Hum. Res. Manage., 54(3):417-421 (5 pages).

Belbin, R.M., (1970). Inspection and human efficiency. Appl. Ergon., 1(5):289-294 (6 pages).

Bentley, C., (2015). The PRINCE2 Practitioner: From Practitioner to Professional.

Bernthal, P.R., (2004). ASTD 2004 competency study: Mapping the future: New workplace learning and performance competencies.  American Society for Training and Development.

Bicheno, J.; Holweg, M., (2000). The lean toolbox (Vol. 4). Buckingham: PICSIE books.

Bridges, W. and Mitchell, S., (2000). Leading transition: A new model for change. Leader to leader, 16(3): 30-36 (7 pages).

Buchanan, R., (1992). Wicked problems in design thinking. Des. Issues, 8(2):5-21 (17 pages).

Chambers, E.G.; Foulon, M.; Handfield-Jones, H.; Hankin, S.M.; Michaels, E.G., (1998). The war for talent. McKinsey Quart.: 44-57 (14 pages).

Chan Kim, W.; Mauborgne, R., (2005). Blue Ocean Strategy: How to create uncontested market space and make the competition irrelevant. . Harvard Business Review Press.  

Christensen, C.M.; Raynor, M.E.; McDonald, R., (2015). What is disruptive innovation? Harv. Bus. Rev., 93(12): 44-53 (10 pages).

Cohen, J., (1960). A coefficient of agreement for nominal scales. New York University.Edu. Psychol. Measure., 20 (1): 37-46 (10 pages).

Collin, A., (1989). Managers’ competence: Rhetoric, reality and research. Pers. Rev., 18(6): 20-25 (6 pages).

Conger, S., (2008). IT. Infrastructure Library (ITIL®).

Cooper, R.G.; (2014). What's Next? After Stage-Gate. Res. Technol. Manage. , 57(1): 20-31 (12 pages).

Corbett, S., (2007). Beyond manufacturing: The evolution of lean. McKinsey Quart, (3): p.96.

Council, a.q., (2002). Australian business excellence framework 2002: the proven vehicle to drive measurable improvement. AQC.

Covey, S., (1989). The seven habits of highly successful people. Fireside/Simon and Schuster.

Covey, S.R.; Merrill, A.R.; Merrill, R.R., (1995). First things first. Simon and Schuster.

Curry, A.; Curry, J., (2002). The customer marketing method: How to implement and profit from customer relationship management. Simon and Schuster.

Curtis, D.B.; Hefley, W.E.; Miller, S.A., (2002). The people capability maturity model: Guidelines for improving the workforce. Addison-Wesley.

De Bono, E., (1985). Master thinker's Handbook: The easy, new guide to innovative thinking. International Center for Creative Thinking.

Dehghani Saryazdi, M., (2014). The effect of km strategies on organizational excellence: With the dynamic system approach. Ph.D. Thesis, Yazd, Technical University. (In Persian)

Delavare, A. (2010), Theoretical and practical research fundamentals in the humanities and social sciences, Tehran: Growth Publication, Eighth Edition. (In Persian)

Delkhosh Kasmaei, A. (2012). The leader model of servant in the organizational excellence of the University of Police", Ph.D. Thesis, Tehran, Allameh Tabatabaei. (In Persian)

Deming, W.E., (1986). Out of the crisis: Quality. Productivity and competitive position, Massachusetts, USA.

Doherty, G.D., (1995). BS 5750 parts 1 and 2/ISO 9000 (series); 1987 and education–do they fit and is it worth it? Qual.  Assur. Educ., 3(3): 3-9 (7 pages).

Drucker, P., (2012). Management challenges for the 21st century. Routledge.

Dyson, P.; Farr, A.; Hollis, N.S., (1996). Understanding, measuring, and using brand equity. J. Advert. Res., 36(6): 9-22 (14 pages).

Edgeman, R., (2018). Excellence models as complex management systems: An examination of the Shingo operational excellence model. Bus. Proc. Manage. J., 24(6): 1321-1338 (68 pages).

Fenz, S.; Goluch, G.; Ekelhart, A.; Riedl, B.; Weippl, E., (2007), December. Information security fortification by ontological mapping of the ISO/IEC 27001 standard. In 13th Pacific Rim International Symposium on Dependable Computing (PRDC 2007):381-388 (8 pages).

Gibson, T.C., (1987). The total quality management resource. Qual. Prog., 20(11): 62-62 (1 page).

Gómez-Gómez, J.; Martínez-Costa, M.; Martínez-Lorente, Á.R., (2016). Weighting the dimensions in models of excellence–a critical review from a business perspective. Measuring Bus. Excellence, 20(3): 79-90 (12 pages).

Greiner, L.E., (1998). Evolution and revolution as organizations grow. Harv. Bus. Rev., 76(3): 55-64 (10 pages).

Hajian, A.; Ahmadvand, A, M.; Movahedi, M., (2013). Performance evaluation model for non-industrial research organizations. J. Hum. Resour. Manage. Res., 5(2):81-105 (25 pages). (In Persian)

Hammer, M., (1990). Reengineering work: don't automate, obliterate. Harv. Bus. Rev., 68(4): 104-112 (9 pages).

Hiatt, J.,(2006). ADKAR: a model for change in business, government, and our community. Prosci.

Hirano, H., (1989). JIT factory revolution: A pictorial guide to factory design of the future. CRC Press.

Hofstede, G., (1984). Culture's consequences: International differences in work-related values, 5. Sage.

Hooman, H. A., (2006).Practical guide to qualitative research, Tehran, Samt publication.

Hosseini ghasr, S.; Zainabadi, H.R.; Alizadeh, m., (2014). An analysis of the methodology and the findings of the researches done in the field of entrepreneurship and characteristics of the entrepreneur. J. Manage. Res. IR., 15 (4): 43-63 (21 pages). (In Persian)

Hoyle, D., (2017). ISO 9000 Quality systems handbook-updated for the ISO 9001: 2015 standard: Increasing the quality of an organization’s outputs. Routledge.

Hsieh, H.F.; Shannon, S.E., (2005). Three approaches to qualitative content analysis. Qual. Health. Res., 15(9): 1277-1288 (12 pages).

Humphrey, W.S.,(1988). Characterizing the software process: a maturity framework. IEEE software, 5(2): 73-79 (7 pages).

Hyder, E.B.; Heston, K.M.; Paulk, M.C.; Hefley, B., (2009). eSourcing capability model for service provider (eSCM-SP). CAPA, 102(0304): 0203.

Imai, M., (2007). gemba kaizen. a commonsense, low-cost approach to management. In das summa summarum desManage., 7-15 (9 pages) (Gabler).

Jahanian, S.; Salehi, M, M., (2015). Extracting interconnected components of internet marketing: A combined research plan. J. Manage. Res. IR, 19 (3): 61-81 (21 pages). (In Persian)

kabaranzad Qadim, M. R.; Mamaghani, A.; Timurnezhad, K., (2015). Investigating the impact of government support policy on small and medium industries in the fourth development plan of the country., J. Manage. Res.  IR., 15: 193-215 (23 pages). ( In Persian).

Kanji, G.K., (1998). Measurement of business excellence. Total Qual. Manage., 9(7): 633-643 (11pages).

Kano, T., (1992). The last ape: Pygmy chimpanzee behavior and ecology,155. (Stanford: Stanford University Press).

Kapferer, J.N., (1994). Strategic brand management: New approaches to creating and evaluating brand equity. Simon and Schuster.

Kaplan, R.S.; Norton, D.P., (1992). The balanced scorecard: measures that drive performance.

Keller, K.L., (1993). Conceptualizing, measuring, and managing customer-based brand equity. J. Marketing, 57(1): 1-22 (22 pages).

Khodadad Hosseini, S, H.; Khodami, S.; Mashbaki, A., (2015). Designing a Market Performance Model Based on Dynamic Marketing Features with Operational Agility Approach. J. Manage. Rese. IR., 19(3): 83-112 (30 pages). (In Persian)

Kotler, P.; Keller, K.L., (2006). Marketing Management 12e. 12. painos. New Jersey: Uppe

Kotter, J.P., (1996). Leading change. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press. Kouzes, JM, and Posner, BZ (2002). The leadership challenge. San Francisco, CA

Kraljic, P., (1983). Purchasing must become supply management. Harv. Bus. Rev., 61(5): 109-117 (9 pages).

Laszlo, G.P., (1997). US and Canadian national quality awards: increased emphasis on business results. The TQM. Mag., 9(5): 381-383 (3 pages).

Learned, E.P.,(1969). Business policy: Text and cases. RD Irwin.

Lee, P.M., (2002). Sustaining business excellence through a framework of best practices in TQM. TQM Mag., 14(3): 142-149 (8 pages).

Lencioni, P., (2006). Overcoming the five dysfunctions of a team. John Wiley and Sons.

Lewin, K., (1946). Action research and minority problems. J. Soc. Iss., 2(4): 34-46 (13 pages).

Lindgreen, A.; Palmer, R.; Vanhamme, J., (2004). Contemporary marketing practice: theoretical propositions and practical implications. Market Intell. Plann., 22(6): 673-692 (20 pages).

Madani, F.S., (2015). Designing and explaining the model of customer excellence process Case Study: Banking and Insurance Industry., Ph.D., Tehran, Tarbiat Modares.  (In Persian)

Mansourian,Y. (2006), Adoption of grounded theory in LIS research New Library World, 9(10): 386-402 (17 pages). (In Persian).

Masaaki, I., (1986). Kaizen: The key to Japan's competitive success. New York, ltd: McGraw-Hill.

McCarthy, E.J., (1960). Basic marketing: a managerial approach. Homewood, IL: Richard D. Irwin. Inc., 1979 McCarthyBasic Marketing: A Managerial Approach1979.

Mesquida, A.L.; Mas, A., Amengual, E.; Calvo-Manzano, J.A., (2012). IT Service Management Process Improvement based on ISO/IEC 15504: A systematic review. Inform. Software Tech., 54(3):239-247 (9 pages).

Mirabile, R.J., (1997). Everything you wanted to know about competency modeling. Train. Dev., 51(8): 73-78 (6 pages).

Mirsapasi, N., Memarzadeh, G., NajafBeigi, M., Alizadeh, M. (2012), "Recognizing the criteria of excellence in the public sector, J.Manage. Gov. Org., 4(2): 53- 70 (18 pages). (In Persian)

Morrison, A.; Wensley, R., (1991). Boxing up or boxed in?: A short history of the Boston Consulting Group share/growth matrix. J MARKET MANAG, 7(2): 105-129 (25pages).

Mosa Khani, M.; Manian, A.; Ahgaqi, E., (2014). Developing a model for assessing collaboration maturity in Shabab network interagency networks. J. Manage. Res. IR., 18(3): 157-180 (24 pages). (In Persian).

Hassanzadeh, H.R.; Khaniifar, H.; Collivand, H.; Asgari, N., (2011). Pathology of organizational structure of central insurance of the Islamic Republic of Iran. Public Admin (University of Tehran), 7: 41-62 (22 pages). (In Persian).

Myers, S.C.; Allen, F., (1991). Principles of corporate finance.

Nabitz, U.W.; Klazinga, N.S., (1999). EFQM approach and the Dutch quality award. Int. J. Health Care Qual. Assur., 12(2): 65-71 (7 pages).

Nakajima, S., (1988). Introduction to TPM: total productive maintenance. (Translation). Productivity Press, Inc., 1988:129 (2 pages).

Narayan, G., (2012). Brand Valuation: A strategic tool for business. IUP. J. Brand Manage., 9(3): 55(1 page).

Nolan, R.L.; Croson, D.C., (1995). Creative destruction: A six-stage process for transforming the organization. Harvard Business Publication.

O’Rourke, D., (2000). Monitoring the monitors: A critique of PricewaterhouseCoopers (PwC) labor monitoring. Department of Urban Studies and Planning Massachusetts Institute of Technology.

Ofman, D., (2001). Core qualities: A gateway to human resources. Schiedam: Scriptum.

Ohmae, K., (1989). The global logic of strategic alliances. Harv. Bus. Rev., 67(2): 143-154 (12 pages).

Ohno, T., (1988). Toyota production system: beyond large-scale production. CRC Press.

Oliveira, M.; Bitencourt, C.; Teixeira, E.; Santos, A.C., (2013). July. Thematic content analysis: Is there a difference between the support provided by the MAXQDA® and NVivo® software packages. In Proceedings of the 12th EURO Conf. Res. Meth. Bus. Manage. Stud.: 304-314 (11 pages).

Osterwalder, A.; Pigneur, Y., (2010). Business model generation: a handbook for visionaries, game changers, and challengers. John Wiley and Sons.

Parasuraman, A.; Zeithaml, V.A.; Berry, L.L., (1988). Servqual: A multiple-item scale for measuring consumer perc. J. Retailing, 64(1): 12.

Payne, A., (2012). Handbook of CRM. Routledge.

Pearce, D.W.; Turner, R.K.; (1990). Economics of natural resources and the environment. JHU Press.

Peña, E., (1990). Motorolas secret to total quality-control. Qual. Prog., 23(10):43-45 (3 pages).

PMI, A., (2013). Guide to the project management body of knowledge (PMBOK guide). In Project Management Institute, 5.

Porter, M.E.; Millar, V.E., (1985). How information gives you competitive advantage.

Porter, M.E., (2008). The five competitive forces that shape strategy. Harv. Bus. Rev., 86(1):25-40 (16 pages).

Rastgar, A, A.; Kahiyari Haghighat, A.; Kahiyari Haghighat, M., (2016. Designing a brand performance model in industrial markets. J. Resour. Manage. Res., 6(1):71-103 (33 pages). (In Persian)

Sandelowski, M.; Barroso, J., (2003). Toward a metasynthesis of qualitative findings on motherhood in HIV‐positive women. Res. Nurs Health, 26(2): 153-170 (18 pages).

Senge, P.M., (2014). The fifth discipline field book: Strategies and tools for building a learning organization. Crown Business.

Sharma, A.K.; Talwar, B., (2007). Evolution of “universal business excellence model” incorporating Vedic philosophy. Measuring Bus. Excellence, 11(3):4-20 (17 pages).

Shingo, S., (2019). A revolution in manufacturing: the SMED system. Routledge.

sireli, y., ozan, E.; kauffmann, P., (2005). a quality function development-based decision model for the avionics industry in the us. In proceedings of the 35th international computers and engineering conference, Istanbul.

Team, C.M.M.I., (2002). Capability Maturity Model® Integration (CMMI), Version 1.1--Continuous Representation.

Treacy, M.; Wiersema, F., (1993). Customer intimacy and other value disciplines. Harv. Bus. Rev., 71(1):84-93 (10 pages).

Tuckman, B.W., (1965). Developmental sequence in small groups. Psychological bulletin, 63(6): 384 (1 page).

Tuttle, B.; Vandervelde, S.D., (2007). An empirical examination of CobiT as an internal control framework for information technology. Int.J. Acc. Inform. Syst., 8(4):240-263 (24 pages).

Ulrich, D., (2012). HR from the outside in: the next era of human resources transformation. McGraw-Hill.

Ulrich, D., Smallwood, N.; Sweetman, K., (2009). The leadership code: five rules to lead by. Harvard Business Press.

Version, T.O.G.A.F., (2009). The open group architecture framework (togaf). The Open Group, 1.

Waterman Jr., R.H., Peters, T.J. and Phillips, J.R., 1980. Structure is not organization. Bus. Horizons, 23(3): 14-26 (13 pages).

Yoji Akao, (2004). Hoshin Kanri: Policy deployment for successful TQM. SteinerBooks.

Young, J.O. and Rubicam, R., (2000). Brand Asset Valuator. Young and Rubicam Inc.

Zagardi, H.; Esmaeili, M., (2010). Influence of information technology on excellence in Iranian Organizations. Manag. Res. IR., 2 (61). (In Persian).


International Journal of Human Capital in Urban Management (IJHCUM) welcomes letters to the editor for the post-publication discussions and corrections which allows debate post publication on its site, through the Letters to Editor. Letters pertaining to manuscript published in IJHCUM should be sent to the editorial office of IJHCUM within three months of either online publication or before printed publication, except for critiques of original research. Following points are to be considering before sending the letters (comments) to the editor.

[1] Letters that include statements of statistics, facts, research, or theories should include appropriate references, although more than three are discouraged.

[2] Letters that are personal attacks on an author rather than thoughtful criticism of the author’s ideas will not be considered for publication.

[3] Letters can be no more than 300 words in length.

[4] Letter writers should include a statement at the beginning of the letter stating that it is being submitted either for publication or not.

[5] Anonymous letters will not be considered.

[6] Letter writers must include their city and state of residence or work.

[7] Letters will be edited for clarity and length.